Asphalt Shingles vs. Metal Roofing: Which is Better?

Asphalt shingle roofing was first introduced in 1901 and is a more durable and economical roofing option than wood shingles and clay tiles.

Although asphalt shingles were considered a revolutionary product in 1901, their popularity declined as longer-lasting, stronger, and more environmentally friendly roofing materials such as metal roofs entered the market.

Today, metal roofs have exploded in popularity and are the second most popular roof type in the country.

Metal roofs can provide the same look as asphalt shingles but with superior durability, longevity and energy efficiency - among other benefits. While the initial cost of metal roofing is slightly higher than asphalt shingles, metal roofing is generally a better investment in the long run and provides a higher return on investment.

What is asphalt shingle roofing?
Asphalt shingles are typically made from a base material such as felt or fiberglass. The substrate is coated with asphalt, a petroleum-based product that acts as a waterproofing agent. The top surface is embedded with mineral or ceramic particles to protect the asphalt coating from UV radiation and the elements.

The two most common styles of asphalt shingles are three-tab shingles and architectural shingles.

Three-tab asphalt shingles are thinner and the same size, while architectural shingles are thicker and vary in size and shape to create a more three-dimensional roof.

 

One of the biggest benefits of asphalt shingles is its price. As we all know, asphalt shingles are the cheapest roofing material, but price and quality are closely related. Asphalt shingles have many disadvantages in terms of quality, durability, longevity, and energy efficiency.

The biggest disadvantage of asphalt shingles is their longevity.

Asphalt shingles need to be replaced every 12 years. This is worth noting if you want to install solar panels on your roof, as solar panels can easily last 25 years or more.

Durability is another major disadvantage of asphalt shingles.

Asphalt shingles are prone to cracking or buckling after just a few years of exposure to the elements. Homeowners who live in areas prone to hail, high winds, tornadoes, or hurricanes should consider more durable roofing materials, as roofing materials can affect insurance premiums. Insurers also make no secret of their preference for homes with durable roofs.

As real estate expert Michael Ryan says:

"Not all roofing materials are created equal when it comes to insurance. Asphalt is more susceptible to damage from windstorms, hail, hurricanes, and tornadoes. This means homeowners with asphalt roofs may pay more than homeowners with other types of roofs. Too much insurance cost."

What is metal roofing?
Metal roofs have been used in the industrial sector for centuries due to their durability, longevity and energy efficiency. However, it is not widely used in residential settings because homeowners consider it "too industrial."

This perception changed with the introduction of stone-coated metal roofs in 1957.

When stone-coated metal roofing entered the market, it gave homeowners the high-performance strength of metal roofing without the industrial look.

Stone-coated metal roofs are made from steel panels that are then coated with stone granules, providing flexibility in shape and a range of colors and textures to replicate the look of traditional materials such as asphalt shingles, clay tiles and wood shake.

In addition to being one of the strongest and most durable roofs on the market, metal roofs are also one of the most energy-efficient and environmentally friendly roofing options.

 

Which is better, asphalt shingles or metal shingles?
So, which one is better, asphalt shingles or metal shingles?

Here's how the two compare in terms of cost, ROI, longevity, energy efficiency, sustainability, durability and maintenance.

 

While asphalt shingles cost slightly less to install, the long-term ROI of metal roofing often makes it a better investment choice. The ROI of metal roofs is hard to beat, mainly because of their durability.

 

Metal roofs are weather-resistant and can stand the test of time in some of the harshest climates in the world.

 

In fact, Progress calls it loud and clear on their website: "If you have a new roof made of a more durable material, like metal, your homeowner's insurance premiums may be lower…"